How Do You Know If Your Business Has Been Hacked? Warning Signs to Watch For

Most business owners picture a cyberattack as something loud: a ransom note on every screen, a website that won’t load, a phone that won’t stop ringing. Some attacks do look like that. Many start much more quietly, with someone logging in as one of your employees and looking around.

The short answer: you often find out from small oddities rather than alarms. It might be an email rule no one remembers creating, a login approval request the employee never triggered, or a vendor calling to ask why your bank details changed. Mandiant, Google’s threat-intelligence and incident-response team, found that intruders in the 2025 attacks it investigated went unnoticed for a median of 14 days. In only 52% of cases did the organization find the problem itself. In the rest, someone outside the company had to tell them.

That gap matters because every quiet day gives an attacker time to read email, learn who approves payments, and set up ways back in. Spotting the early signs can turn a serious incident into a contained one.

In this blog post, we will explain why break-ins often go unnoticed, walk through five warning signs that owners and employees can spot without technical tools, and list the questions worth asking your IT provider. We will also show how Techmedics’ managed security services can help you catch what people miss.

Why Many Break-Ins Go Unnoticed

Security teams call the time between a break-in and its discovery “dwell time.” It tends to run long when the attacker doesn’t need to break anything. Someone who signs in with a stolen password looks, to most systems, like an ordinary employee checking email. Passwords leak in many ways, including reuse across sites that were breached.

Unnoticed access also tends to come back later. Mandiant calls this “prior compromise,” meaning access from an earlier break-in that was never cleaned up. It was the third most common way attackers got in during 2025. It was also the top way into ransomware attacks, at 30%, double the year before. A quiet intrusion this month can become a ransomware attack next month.

One caveat: Mandiant’s figures come only from incidents it was called in to investigate, so they may not reflect smaller businesses. A small business without anyone watching its logs may take longer to notice, not shorter.

5 Warning Signs Owners and Employees Can Spot

1. Login Approval Requests Nobody Asked For

Multifactor authentication (MFA) adds a second check, such as tapping “approve” on a phone, after the password. If an employee gets approval requests they didn’t trigger, the password may already be stolen. The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), the federal government’s cyber defense agency, describes a tactic called “push bombing,” where attackers flood a phone with requests until the user taps “approve” by accident or just to make them stop. A related trick is a phone call from fake “IT support” asking the employee to approve a prompt, the same approach behind recent helpdesk impersonation scams. Voice phishing was the second most common way in across Mandiant’s 2025 investigations, at 11%.

Microsoft 365 lets users report an unexpected prompt as suspicious, which flags the account as high risk for an administrator. That option stays off unless an administrator turns it on.

CISA’s preferred fix for push bombing is phishing-resistant MFA, such as a physical security key. As an interim step, it recommends number matching, where the user types a code shown on the login screen before approving. Not every MFA method offers the same protection, as the risks of text-message codes and SIM swapping show.

2. Strange Email Rules and Missing Messages

Once inside a mailbox, attackers often set up inbox rules (automatic sorting instructions) to hide their tracks. Microsoft’s own guide to compromised email accounts lists several warning signs. One is a rule forwarding mail to unknown addresses. Another is a rule moving messages into rarely opened folders such as Notes, Junk Email, or RSS Subscriptions. Email that goes missing or gets deleted is a third. If an employee says replies from a client “never arrived,” that is worth a closer look.

3. Messages You Didn’t Send

Microsoft’s list also includes odd messages sitting in Sent Items or Deleted Items, such as an “I’m stuck in London, send money” note. Another sign is a mailbox suddenly blocked from sending email, which Microsoft says is likely if the account was used to send spam or a high volume of email. Clients or coworkers replying to messages you never wrote point in the same direction.

4. Vendors or Clients Asking About Payment Changes

Business email compromise (BEC) is fraud in which a criminal uses a real or look-alike email account to redirect payments, often by sending “updated” bank details. The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) recorded 24,768 BEC complaints and more than $3 billion in reported losses in 2025. California and Texas ranked first and second in reported losses across all internet crime that year. Both states are home to Techmedics markets, including Los Angeles, Pasadena, Irvine, and Dallas.

The warning sign often arrives from outside. A supplier asks why you changed your remittance details. A client mentions the invoice “you” resent. Home closings are one place this shows up. IC3’s own 2025 case examples include a fraudulent wire of more than $1.3 million tied to fake title company instructions. The FBI recommends confirming any change in payment details through a second channel, such as a phone number you already have on file.

5. Unexplained Account Changes

Microsoft also points to frequent password changes, unexplained lockouts, edited contact details in the company directory, and strange new email signatures. Its cleanup steps go further: check for new sign-in devices or MFA methods, apps the user granted access to, and administrator rights the account shouldn’t have. An owner won’t see most of these directly, but an employee saying “I keep getting locked out” is a cue to ask your IT provider to check.

If You Spot One of These Signs

Call your IT provider first, by phone. Microsoft advises against emailing a new password to the affected user, since the attacker may still be reading that mailbox. The usual first steps are disabling the account, signing it out everywhere, and removing any rules or forwarding the attacker added. If money has already moved, contact your bank and file a report at ic3.gov quickly, since the FBI notes that time matters when trying to freeze fraudulent transfers.

Before Moving Forward, Business Leaders Should Ask:

  • Would we know within a day if someone created an email rule forwarding messages outside the company?
  • Can employees report an unexpected login approval request, and does someone actually review those reports?
  • Do our logins use number matching or a phishing-resistant method, such as a physical security key, rather than a simple “approve” button?
  • Does anyone review sign-in activity, such as unusual locations or times, on a regular schedule?
  • Does everyone who handles payments confirm bank-detail changes by calling a number already on file?

How Techmedics Can Help

  • Continuous monitoring: Our managed security services watch for suspicious sign-ins, mailbox rules, and account changes so problems surface sooner.
  • Microsoft 365 security settings: Through our cloud services, we turn on suspicious-activity reporting, number matching, and forwarding controls that are often left at their defaults.
  • A helpdesk employees can call: Our IT helpdesk services give staff a known number to report odd prompts or lockouts, so they don’t have to take the word of a caller claiming to be IT.
  • Fast response when something is wrong: We disable compromised accounts, remove attacker access, and help you document what happened.
  • Payment-fraud safeguards: We help finance and real estate teams set up verification habits around payment changes.

If you’re not sure whether anyone would notice a quiet break-in at your business, request a consultation today with Techmedics.

‍

‍

Talk With a Technology Advisor

Technology challenges rarely have one-size-fits-all solutions. A consultation with Techmedics can help you better understand your options and identify practical next steps for your organization. Start with a conversation about what you're trying to accomplish and where technology may be getting in the way.

Your request has been sent.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.