Does Security Awareness Training Actually Work?

November 16, 2026

Most businesses depend on email to bill clients, pay vendors, and share files, which makes the inbox one of the easiest ways into a company. Phishing, the fake emails and messages that trick people into giving up passwords or money, is a big part of the problem. Verizon’s 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report notes that the most frequent causes of breaches continue to involve the human element, including phishing and stolen passwords.

The usual answer is security awareness training: an annual course, plus fake “test” phishing emails sent to staff throughout the year. Many owners pay for it, and insurers and clients may ask whether it is in place. So it is fair to ask whether it works.

The short answer: training helps a little, but much less than most people assume. One of the largest controlled studies of phishing training found that annual training made no measurable difference in who clicked on phishing emails, and follow-up training after a click made only a small one. Training is still worth doing. It just cannot be the main thing standing between an employee and a fake email.

In this blog post, we will look at what the research found, why training falls short on its own, and the safeguards that make it pay off. We will also explain how Techmedics’ managed security services can help you build a program that does not depend on every employee being perfect.

What the Research Found

In 2025, researchers at UC San Diego and the University of Chicago published one of the largest real-world tests of phishing training, presented at a leading peer-reviewed security research conference, the IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy. Over eight months, they sent ten simulated phishing campaigns to more than 19,500 employees at UC San Diego Health, a large healthcare organization. Employees were randomly assigned to different types of training, and some received none, so the results could be compared fairly.

1. Annual Training Showed No Measurable Effect

The researchers found no significant link between how recently an employee had completed the yearly awareness course and whether they clicked a phishing link. Employees who had just finished their annual training clicked about as often as those who took it months earlier.

2. Training After a Click Helped, but Only Slightly

When an employee clicked a test email, they were shown a short lesson on the spot. That “embedded” training produced a statistically significant drop in failure rates, but only about 2 percentage points. Most people barely engaged with it: over half of the lessons were closed within 10 seconds, and fewer than 24% of users finished the material. The small group who completed the interactive version did better, about 19% less likely to click the next test, though the researchers caution that those may simply have been more careful employees to begin with.

3. Most People Clicked Eventually

Across the study, 56% of employees clicked at least one phishing link, whether or not they had been trained. Over time, the number of people who had clicked at least once kept climbing.

4. The Email Mattered More Than the Training

The type of message made a far bigger difference than any training. A fake password warning fooled under 2% of recipients. A fake email about a change to the vacation policy fooled almost 31%. One likely reason: people are good at spotting the scams they have been warned about many times and much worse at spotting a believable message about everyday work.

The authors concluded that phishing training, as most organizations deliver it today, is unlikely to meaningfully reduce phishing risk on its own. They suggested that technical safeguards, such as hardware-based multifactor authentication (a physical key the employee must have on hand to sign in) and password managers that only fill in passwords on the real website, may offer a better return.

Why This Matters for a Small Business

A small business does not have a security team watching every login. If an employee enters a password on a fake page, or approves a fake invoice, the mistake may not surface until money or data is gone. Business email compromise is the scam where a criminal poses as a vendor, boss, or client by email to redirect a payment. The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) received reports of more than $3 billion in losses from it in 2025, the second-highest loss category after investment fraud.

Healthcare and dental offices may feel this most, since front-desk and billing staff handle patient data and payments every day. The study notes that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) recommends annual awareness training and monthly simulated phishing for medium and large healthcare organizations. The study itself took place in a hospital system, but the lesson applies just as well to a small practice. For practices that work with Techmedics’ healthcare IT team, the findings suggest putting more of the effort into safeguards that do not rely on people. We still recommend keeping training in place, because it covers new scams and is often expected by insurers and clients.

As we have written before, many businesses run a single annual session and assume the job is done. The research suggests that even well-run training will not get click rates close to zero, because a believable new message can still catch someone who spotted the last one.

4 Safeguards to Pair With Training

1. Login Protection That Phishing Cannot Easily Steal

Multifactor authentication (MFA) asks for a second proof of identity beyond a password. Some forms are stronger than others. The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) calls phishing-resistant MFA the “gold standard.” Examples include a physical security key and a passkey, a sign-in built into a phone or laptop that replaces the password. Because these only work on the real website, a fooled employee generally cannot hand the login to a fake one.

2. A One-Click Report Button and a Fast Response

When one employee spots a phishing email, everyone else who got it is still at risk. Microsoft 365 includes a built-in Report button in Outlook that sends suspicious messages for review. The button only helps if someone acts on the reports quickly, removes the message from other inboxes, and thanks the person who reported it.

3. A Callback Rule for Payments and Account Changes

Many costly scams involve no link at all, just an email asking to change a vendor’s bank details or send a rush payment. The FBI recommends verifying these requests through a second channel. This matters because the study measured link clicks, and many of these scams have no link to click, so a good phishing-test score says little about this risk. A simple rule works: any change to payment details gets a phone call to a number already on file, never one in the email.

4. Shorter, More Frequent Training That Is Measured by Reporting

Training still has a place, especially for the newer scams employees have not seen, such as fake QR codes and CAPTCHA pages. The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), in its guide to building a security learning program, suggests metrics for regularly measuring and updating a program. In practice, that means short sessions through the year and tracking how many people report a test email, not just how many finished the course.

Before Moving Forward, Business Leaders Should Ask:

  • Do we know what our phishing test click rate is, and how many employees report test emails?
  • Does every employee have MFA on email, and is it a phishing-resistant method for administrators and finance staff?
  • Can staff report a suspicious email with one click, and does someone respond the same day?
  • Do we require a phone callback before changing any vendor’s payment details?
  • Is our training short, regular, and based on current scams rather than one long annual course?

How Techmedics Can Help

  • Layered Email and Login Protection: Our managed security services combine email filtering, phishing-resistant MFA, and monitoring so one click does not become a breach.
  • Report-and-Respond Process: We set up one-click reporting and review reported emails quickly, removing confirmed threats from every inbox.
  • Practical Awareness Training: We run short, regular training and phishing tests built around current scams, and we track reporting rates alongside click rates.
  • Payment and Account-Change Controls: We help you put callback and approval rules in place for invoices, wire transfers, and vendor changes.
  • Industry-Specific Support: For healthcare, dental, and other regulated offices, we match training and safeguards with what your industry and insurers expect.

To find out whether your training is paying off and what to add around it, schedule a consultation with Techmedics.

‍

Talk With a Technology Advisor

Technology challenges rarely have one-size-fits-all solutions. A consultation with Techmedics can help you better understand your options and identify practical next steps for your organization. Start with a conversation about what you're trying to accomplish and where technology may be getting in the way.

Your request has been sent.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.